Advocate General Hogan (the Irish Advocate General in the European Court of Justice) has given his Opinion in Case C-872/19 P (Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela v Council) in an appeal by the Venezuelan state against a refusal by the General Court to annul various provisions in the EU’s sanctions on Venezuela in Regulation (EU) 2017/2063. The press release is here.
The General Court (the lower court) had found in Case T-65/18 (20 September 2019) that the Republic of Venezuela did not have standing (locus standi) to bring the challenge because it was not one of the listed targets of sanctions and so did not satisfy the EU test for standing in Article 264 TFEU (previous post). This was in line with sanctions de-listing cases where the EU court has held that only the people / entities listed in the annex to targeted sanctions should be able to bring cases.
The Advocate General disagrees, and thinks this line of cases should be re-considered, and that the European court should follow international law practice in permitting sovereign States to bring proceedings. He considers that the state is a “legal person” directly affected by the EU’s sanctions not least because they prevent the Venezuelan republic from buying goods and services from some EU operators, and that it is “wholly irrelevant” whether it is named in the annex or in the body of the sanctions regulation.
This opinion is not binding on the European Court of Justice, which will now decide on the appeal.
Source: European Sanctions